Prescription of Tax Assessments – Is SARS having it both ways?
Prescription of Tax Assessments – Is SARS having it both ways?
By Esther van Schalkwyk, Associate Director
This article first appeared in the July 2026 edition of Accountancy SA’s - Integritax Journal
(www.accountancysa.org.za/integritax/)
Introduction
The South African Revenue Service (SARS) is tasked with administering the tax Acts but must do so within the confines of the laws that govern it – most notably the Tax Administration Act 28 of 2011 (the Tax Admin Act). When issuing additional assessments, SARS should also consider compensating adjustments in favour of the taxpayer, especially when relying on the exception to the prescription period in the case of fraud, misrepresentation or non-disclosure of material facts. In practice this is not always the case.
Additional assessments
If SARS is satisfied that an assessment does not reflect the correct application of a tax Act to the prejudice of SARS or the fiscus, SARS must make an additional assessment to correct the prejudice (per section 92 of the Tax Admin Act).
The prejudice to SARS or the fiscus should be determined based on the correct application of the tax Act. Where a taxpayer “got it wrong”, SARS must determine the correct amount of tax payable under the circumstances and thereafter determine the prejudice as representing the difference between the two scenarios. Although the term “prejudice” has been given a much wider interpretation in the context of understatement penalties, surely prejudice in the context of determining the correct application of a tax Act should take into account all the provisions of that Act. As held by the Constitutional Court in Capitec Bank Limited v Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service [2024] ZACC 1: “SARS, as an organ of state subject to the Constitution, should not seek to exact tax which is not due and payable.”
SARS should therefore also take into account compensating adjustments in favour of the taxpayer when determining the prejudice which it seeks to correct, for example, where a taxpayer applied the wrong section of a tax Act but would have qualified for relief under a different section.
Section 92 (on additional assessments) should be read with section 99 of the Tax Admin Act (on the prescription of assessments), since the latter section may prohibit SARS from raising an additional assessment after a certain period.
Period of limitations for issuance of assessments
SARS is generally prohibited from making an assessment more than three years after the date of an original assessment by SARS or five years after the date of a self-assessment.
Where more than three years have elapsed from the original assessment (five years in the case of a self-assessment) SARS often relies on the exceptions contained in section 99(2)(a)-(b) of the Tax Admin Act. These exceptions are:
- In the case of an assessment by SARS, where the full amount of tax chargeable was not assessed due to fraud, misrepresentation or non-disclosure of material facts; or
- In the case of a self-assessment, where the full amount of tax chargeable was not assessed due to fraud, intentional or negligent misrepresentation, intentional or negligent non-disclosure of material facts or the failure to submit a return or, if no return is required, the failure to make the required payment of tax.
SARS may therefore still raise an assessment regardless of the period which has elapsed where there was fraud, misrepresentation or non-disclosure of material facts.
The exception to the prescription period (sometimes referred to as lifting the veil of prescription) is not open-ended and only applies “to the extent that … the fact that the full amount of tax chargeable was not assessed, was due to” [fraud, misrepresentation or non-disclosure of material facts].
To determine whether the full amount of tax chargeable was assessed, SARS should surely take into account all the provisions of the relevant tax Act, including compensating adjustments in favour of the taxpayer. Once the full amount of tax chargeable has been determined, SARS is only allowed to lift the veil of prescription to the extent thereof, and no further.
Conclusion and submission
Compensating adjustments in favour of the taxpayer should factor into the determination of the prejudice suffered by SARS or the fiscus (required where SARS makes an additional assessment) and the extent to which the full amount of tax chargeable was not assessed (required where SARS lifts the veil of prescription). In practice this is not always the case.
SARS has in the past lifted the veil of prescription to issue additional assessments while refusing to entertain compensating adjustments. Instead, the taxpayer was advised to submit a request for reduced assessments which would, in any event, be rejected owing to the prescription period. This resulted in additional assessments in which SARS assessed the taxpayer for tax in excess of the prejudice suffered by SARS or the fiscus and beyond the full amount of tax chargeable. Should SARS have it both ways – lifting the veil of prescription when appropriate but stepping back in when convenient?