By Shirlynn Smith, Manager and Associate Professor David Warneke, Partner

Even an unintentional error can carry significant financial consequences. The narrowing of the bona fide inadvertent error defence under the 2026 amendments to the Tax Administration Act, 2011 (TAA), means that there are more situations in which the severe understatement penalty regime will apply. The amendment fundamentally changes South Africa’s understatement penalty landscape, placing renewed emphasis on reasonable care, informed tax positions and the importance of obtaining timely professional tax assistance.

Mistakes are inevitable and even taxpayers who genuinely intend to comply with their tax obligations may make errors when interpreting legislation, calculating deductions or completing tax returns. An error made in good faith clearly does not necessarily mean that reasonable care was exercised.

The legislative amendment

As adumbrated above, the distinction between errors made in good faith, where reasonable care was taken in completing the return and where it was not, has assumed greater significance following amendments to sections 222 and 223 of the TAA introduced by the Tax Administration Laws Amendment Act 4 of 2026, which came into effect on 1 April 2026.

The amendments materially restrict the circumstances in which taxpayers may rely on the bona fide inadvertent error defence to avoid understatement penalties.

While the changes may appear technical, their practical implications are far-reaching, particularly for taxpayers who prepare their own returns without obtaining appropriate professional assistance.

Before the amendments, section 222(1) of the TAA provided a general exclusion from understatement penalties where an understatement resulted from a bona fide inadvertent error. In principle, this protection was available irrespective of the monetary value of the understatement or the behaviour category that might otherwise have applied.

The 2026 amendments removed this general exclusion from section 222(1) and introduced specific relief under section 223(3)(a). Under the amended provision, an understatement penalty that results from a bona fide inadvertent error will only be remitted if the penalty is imposed for a ‘substantial understatement’ as defined. Of most practical import, a bona fide inadvertent error is no longer protected from understatement penalties imposed for the categories:

  • Reasonable care not taken in completing return;
  • No reasonable grounds for tax position taken; and
  • Impermissible avoidance arrangement.

Also, a bona fide inadvertent error where the quantum of prejudice to SARS or the fiscus falls below R1 million would lead to the imposition of an understatement penalty, if the behaviour falls into one of the bulleted categories above. This is because to fall into the category of ‘substantial understatement’ where the bona fide inadvertent error defence may apply, the prejudice must exceed the greater of R1 million or 5% of tax properly chargeable or refundable. Although it may appear ironic that taxpayers whose bona fide inadvertent errors fall below the ‘substantial understatement’ threshold may, unlike taxpayers whose bona fide inadvertent errors are greater in quantum, no longer rely on this general exclusion from the imposition of understatement penalties, this comparison is, at least in theory, misleading. This is because on a like-for-like comparison of these two situations, SARS would only be able to impose any penalty for an error that fell below the ‘substantial understatement’ threshold if it could show that one of the unacceptable behaviours was present, for example ‘reasonable care not taken’. And if that same behaviour were present where the quantum of the error exceeded the ‘substantial understatement’ threshold, SARS would be obliged to impose the higher penalty, in which case the penalty for ‘substantial understatement’ would fall away.

The above analysis does not mean that every incorrect tax return will automatically attract a penalty. For an understatement penalty to apply, SARS still bears the burden of proving the conduct required under the applicable behavioural category in the understatement penalty table.

The amendments militate in favour of procuring the timely advice and assistance of knowledgeable tax practitioners. And this is not only because errors are less likely to arise when tax practitioners are engaged. By engaging a tax practitioner to check the calculation and return before submission to SARS, the client is taking a reasonable step to ensure compliance - and is therefore less likely to be found to have been negligent, for example by not having taken reasonable care.  

What is meant by a ‘bona fide inadvertent error’?

In ITC 1890 79 SATC 62, the Tax Court interpreted the term ‘bona fide inadvertent error’ as ‘an innocent misstatement by a taxpayer on his or her return, resulting in an understatement, while acting in good faith and without the intention to deceive’. SARS adopted a narrower interpretation in its Guide to Understatement Penalties (Issue 2), concluding that ‘the only errors that may fall within the bona fide inadvertent class are typographical mistakes, but only properly involuntary ones’, and SARS further clarified that a lack of reasonable care will not be excused. There was thus a conflicting view between the judgment in ITC 1890 and the guidance provided by SARS, with the interpretation adopted by SARS the more restrictive of the interpretations. Thereafter, the proverbial waters were further clouded by a series of judgments of our highest courts.

In CSARS v The Thistle Trust 85 SATC 347, the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) considered the incorrect tax treatment of capital gains distributed through a tiered trust structure. Although SARS succeeded on the substantive tax issue, the understatement penalty was set aside. The Court understood SARS to have conceded that the taxpayer’s understatement constituted a bona fide inadvertent error even though the taxpayer had obtained legal advice supporting the tax treatment adopted.

The Constitutional Court, to which the matter proceeded on appeal (reported as The Thistle Trust v CSARS 87 SATC 103) subsequently declined to determine the precise meaning of the term ‘bona fide inadvertent error’. It considered it undesirable to decide the issue without the benefit of fully reasoned judgments on the issue from the preceding courts. Nevertheless, the Constitutional Court emphasised that SARS bears the burden of establishing the conduct relied upon to justify an understatement penalty and found that SARS had no reasonable prospects of discharging that burden in the circumstances.

In CSARS v Coronation Investment Management SA (Pty) Ltd 85 SATC 413, the SCA considered understatement penalties arising from the taxpayer’s application of the foreign business establishment exemption. The Court rejected the inference that the taxpayer had deliberately failed to comply with its tax obligations merely because its tax position was incorrect. The Court also rejected speculation concerning the contents of a tax opinion that had not been produced. The Court accordingly held that the understatement penalties that SARS had imposed could not be sustained.

The Constitutional Court (in Coronation Investment Management SA (Pty) Limited v CSARS 87 SATC 150) subsequently overturned the SCA’s decision on the substantive issue, finding in favour of the taxpayer. Consequently, the question of understatement penalties did not arise for determination.

As a result of the above judgments from our highest courts, there is uncertainty whether an incorrect tax position that is deliberately adopted by a taxpayer, albeit in good faith, can amount to a ‘bona fide inadvertent error’.

Whatever the boundaries of the term, the 2026 amendments have restricted the scope of its application, in that taxpayers can no longer rely on it as a general defence against understatement penalties. The practical implication is that the exercise of reasonable care assumes greater significance.

Reasonable care: an increasingly important consideration

The increasing complexity of South Africa’s tax legislation and the potentially significant consequences of non-compliance have elevated the importance of professional tax assistance and advice. Tax practitioners play a critical role in assisting taxpayers to interpret legislation, identify potential errors and ensure that tax returns accurately reflect the relevant facts and applicable legal requirements. Their involvement is particularly valuable where compliance requires specialist knowledge or the application of complex legislative provisions.

This role is particularly significant in the context of understatement penalties, where section 223 of the TAA expressly identifies a failure to take reasonable care in completing a return as a category of culpable behaviour.

Reasonable care is concerned not only with the accuracy of the return ultimately submitted, but also with the steps taken to ensure its accuracy. The enquiry is therefore directed at the taxpayer’s conduct in the circumstances, including whether appropriate measures were taken to identify errors, verify information and obtain specialist assistance where necessary.

The involvement of a knowledgeable tax practitioner may be particularly relevant to this enquiry. By reviewing a return before submission, evaluating the tax treatment of transactions and identifying potential omissions or inaccuracies, a practitioner can assist taxpayers in taking proactive and demonstrable steps towards compliance.

The significance of professional advice was recognised in Attieh v Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service 84 SATC 420. In that matter, the Gauteng High Court considered the taxpayer’s reliance on expert tax advice in adopting a disputed capital gains tax treatment.

Importantly, Meyer J recorded that the Tax Court had found that, having obtained advice from a tax practitioner, the taxpayer had reasonable grounds for the position adopted and could not be said to have failed to exercise reasonable care in completing the return. The Tax Court had been persuaded by the following dictum in Estate of Spruill v Commissioner (88 TC 1197 (1987)), which is a decision of the Tax Court in the United States of America:

‘When an accountant or attorney advises a taxpayer on a matter of tax law, such as whether a liability exists, it is reasonable for the taxpayer to rely on that advice.’

Significantly, Meyer J endorsed the Tax Court’s conclusion that the taxpayer’s reliance on professional advice was reasonable.

The judgment is particularly relevant because it illustrates the evidentiary value of professional advice when evaluating a taxpayer’s conduct. While reasonable care and reasonable grounds for a tax position are distinct categories under section 223 of the TAA, the steps taken to obtain competent professional advice may be relevant to both enquiries, depending on the circumstances.

The courts have nevertheless emphasised that professional assistance must be accompanied by meaningful taxpayer engagement. In M Family Trust v Commissioner for the South African Revenue Services 79 SATC 266, the Tax Court considered whether reasonable care had been exercised where returns had been prepared with the assistance of a tax practitioner.

Allie J cautioned that:

‘A taxpayer cannot disavow himself/herself of tax responsibilities by relying on an accountant or tax practitioner as the tax practitioner is only obliged declare (sic) information on tax returns as provided by the taxpayer.’

The court found that reasonable care had not been exercised in the particular circumstances. This finding does not diminish the importance of professional tax advice. Rather, it reinforces the need for meaningful collaboration between taxpayers and practitioners, with taxpayers providing complete and accurate information and practitioners applying their specialist knowledge and professional judgment to the matters entrusted to them.

This distinction is important because lay taxpayers are not expected to possess the technical knowledge of a qualified tax practitioner. However, where tax legislation is complex or uncertain, obtaining competent professional assistance may be one of the most effective steps available to taxpayers in managing their compliance obligations and demonstrating reasonable care.

These decisions reinforce the importance of viewing reasonable care as a substantive compliance obligation rather than a procedural formality. Engaging a tax practitioner is not simply an exercise in delegating responsibility. Where professional assistance involves a meaningful review, appropriate technical analysis and the identification of compliance risks, it may constitute important evidence of the taxpayer's efforts to meet the required standard of care.

One of the most significant implications of the amendments concerns the exercise of reasonable care when completing a tax return, because penalties for this behaviour category are applied more frequently in practice than the other behaviour categories. Under section 223(1) of the TAA, a failure to take reasonable care attracts an understatement penalty of 25% in a standard case and 50% if obstructive, or if it is a repeat case.

Section 223 opinions

The TAA also expressly recognises the significance of independent professional tax advice. As a separate relief, section 223(3)(b) provides for the remission of a penalty imposed for a substantial understatement where a supporting opinion from a registered tax practitioner is obtained. The prescribed requirements include full disclosure of the relevant arrangement to SARS and being in possession of an opinion from an independent registered tax practitioner that supports the taxpayer’s position. The opinion must have been issued by no later than the due date of the relevant return, be based on full disclosure of the relevant facts and circumstances and confirm that the taxpayer’s position is more likely than not to be upheld, if the matter proceeds to court. Although these statutory requirements apply specifically to the remission of penalties imposed for a substantial understatement, obtaining competent professional advice may also assist taxpayers in demonstrating reasonable care.

The distinction is therefore between obtaining assistance and advice as a proactive compliance measure compared with obtaining it only after an error has been identified. The former may help prevent errors, support defensible tax positions and reduce exposure to understatement penalties.

Conclusion

The 2026 amendments represent a significant shift in South Africa’s understatement penalty framework. By restricting the bona fide inadvertent error defence, the legislation places greater emphasis on taxpayer conduct and the steps taken to ensure compliance.

While an incorrect tax position does not automatically justify an understatement penalty, the possibility has been removed that an error made in good faith will, by itself, protect a taxpayer from potential understatement penalties. The taxpayer must be able to demonstrate that reasonable care was taken with the submission of its tax return and that there were reasonable grounds for any tax positions adopted. The timely assistance of knowledgeable tax practitioners is therefore even more important than before.